KahniyanStories worth reading twice

The Clock That Ran Slow

There was a clock in a hallway that ran four minutes slow, and had done for as long as anyone could remember.

Everybody in that house knew it. It was not a problem. If you wanted to know the real time you looked at the clock and added four minutes, and everybody did this without thinking about it, including the children, who had learned it before they learned to read.

The visitor

An uncle came to stay for a week and it drove him to distraction.

"Why do you not fix it?"

"It is not broken," said the grandmother. "It is four minutes slow. That is a different thing."

"It is the same thing."

"A broken clock tells you nothing," she said. "This one tells you the time. It just tells it to you four minutes ago."

The uncle took it down on the third day and opened the back of it and adjusted something, and put it up again, and stood there looking pleased.

The week after

Everything went slightly wrong for about a week.

People were early for things by four minutes, which does not sound like much and is enough to be standing outside a shop before it opens. The children got to school four minutes early and had to wait at the gate. The milk was collected before it arrived twice.

Nobody could quite work out why, because they all knew the clock had been corrected, and they were all still adding four minutes without noticing they were doing it.

The grandmother

She let it run for the whole week and said nothing.

Then on the Sunday she took the clock down, opened the back, and put it four minutes slow again.

The uncle watched her do it.

"You cannot be serious."

"You were right and the clock was wrong," she said. "But everybody in this house had already worked around it, years ago, and the working around was the thing that was actually keeping time. You fixed the clock and broke the household."

She hung it back up.

"Nobody minds a thing being slightly wrong," she said, "as long as it is wrong in exactly the same way every day."

Afterwards

It ran four minutes slow for another eleven years.

When the grandmother died the family sold the house, and the clock went to a cousin, and the first thing he did when he got it home was open the back and correct it, because he did not know.

And that was fine, because in his house nobody was adding anything.

Moral of the story

The clock was wrong the whole time and the house ran perfectly. What matters is not whether a thing is right, but whether everybody knows the same thing about it.

Questions and answers

  1. What was wrong with the clock?

    It ran four minutes slow and always had.

  2. How did the household manage?

    Everybody added four minutes automatically, including the children, who had learned it before they could read.

  3. What did the uncle do?

    He took the clock down, corrected it, and put it back.

  4. Why did things go wrong afterwards?

    Everybody was still adding four minutes out of habit, so they were early for everything.

  5. Why did the grandmother set it slow again?

    Because the household's habit of adding four minutes was what was actually keeping time, and correcting the clock broke that.

Word meanings

distraction
A state of being unable to concentrate, often from annoyance.
adjusted
Changed slightly to make something work differently.
household
Everyone living together in one house.
corrected
Made right.

Questions about The Clock That Ran Slow

What is the moral of The Clock That Ran Slow?

That consistency can matter more than accuracy. A predictable error everybody understands works better than a correction nobody expects.

Is the uncle wrong?

He is right about the clock and wrong about the house, which is what makes the story worth discussing.

Why does the cousin correcting it not matter?

Because nobody in his house had the habit of adding four minutes, so there was nothing to break.

What age suits this story?

Ages five to nine, though older children usually enjoy arguing about who was right.