KahniyanStories worth reading twice

The Song the River Learned

A river came down out of the hills making a great deal of noise about it.

Up there it was all rock and drop and hurry. It crashed and roared and threw itself down ledges, and it was extremely pleased with the sound it made, which could be heard from a long way off.

"Listen to that," it said. "There is nothing quieter than a river that has stopped moving. Noise is the whole point."

Down onto the flat

Then the hills ended and the land went flat.

And the river slowed right down.

It could not crash any more because there was nothing to crash off. It spread out wide and shallow and went along at a walking pace between low banks, and the noise it made was almost nothing at all: a small continuous sound, more like breathing than anything else.

The river was ashamed of this for a long time.

What happened on the flat

But things began to happen on the flat that had never happened in the hills.

Reeds grew, which they could not do in fast water. Then birds came for the reeds. Fish that could not have held their place upstream lived here in numbers, and turtles, and a family of otters.

A village put itself on the bank. Then a second one further down. Children learned to swim in the shallow part by the bend, and women washed clothes on the flat stones, and in the evening people came and sat by the water simply because it was a good place to sit.

Nobody had ever sat beside the river in the hills. You could not have heard yourself think.

The evening sound

One evening a very old woman sat on the bank with a grandchild who would not settle.

And she said, "Listen to the river."

The child listened.

And that small continuous sound, which the river had been ashamed of for years, went into the child the way that sound does, and slowed everything down, and after a few minutes the child was asleep on the old woman's shoulder.

The river heard the whole thing.

It has never gone back to the hills, and it does not talk about the crashing any more, and every evening now it does the thing it turned out to be for.

Moral of the story

What you are loudest at is not always what you are best at. The river was proud of the noise and useful for the quiet.

Questions and answers

  1. What was the river like in the hills?

    Fast, loud and crashing, and very proud of the noise it made.

  2. What changed when the land went flat?

    It slowed down, spread out wide and shallow, and made almost no sound at all.

  3. Why was the river ashamed?

    It believed noise was the whole point of being a river, so being quiet felt like failing.

  4. What happened on the flat that never happened in the hills?

    Reeds grew, birds and fish and otters came, villages settled on the banks, and people sat by the water in the evenings.

  5. What did the river finally understand?

    That its quiet sound was more useful than its loud one, when it heard a child fall asleep to it.

Word meanings

ledge
A flat shelf of rock sticking out.
shallow
Not deep.
continuous
Going on without stopping.
ashamed
Feeling bad about yourself over something.

Questions about The Song the River Learned

What is the moral of The Song the River Learned?

That the thing you are proudest of is not always the thing you are best at. The river's quiet stretch did far more good than its loud one.

Is the natural detail accurate?

Yes. Reeds, turtles and slow-water fish genuinely need calm shallow stretches, and settlements really do form on slow reaches rather than fast ones.

Why does the story end with a sleeping child?

Because it is a bedtime story and the last image should be the one the listener carries into sleep.

What is a good conversation afterwards?

Ask what sound helps the child fall asleep. Rain, a fan, traffic and voices in another room all come up, and it is a calm thing to talk about.