KahniyanStories worth reading twice

The Monkey and the Crocodile

Also known as Bandar aur Magarmach

On the bank of a wide river grew a jamun tree, heavy with purple fruit all year round. In its branches lived a monkey named Raktamukha, who had never in his life been hungry.

One hot afternoon a crocodile hauled himself out of the river and lay panting in the shade of the tree. The monkey looked down at him.

"You look tired, friend," he called. "Have some fruit."

He picked the ripest jamuns he could find and dropped them down. The crocodile ate them, and they were the sweetest thing he had ever tasted.

A friendship across the water

After that the crocodile came every day. The monkey would drop fruit, and the two of them would talk until the sun went low. They became true friends, which is a strange thing for a monkey and a crocodile to be.

One evening the crocodile said, "My wife has never tasted these. May I take some home?"

"Take as many as you like," said the monkey.

So the crocodile carried a bundle of jamuns home to his wife. She ate them, and then she sat very still for a long time.

"Husband," she said at last, "if the fruit is this sweet, imagine the monkey. He has eaten nothing but this fruit his whole life. His heart must be sweeter than anything in the world. I want it."

The crocodile's terrible choice

The crocodile was horrified. "He is my friend," he said. "I will not."

But his wife would not let it go. She refused to eat. She refused to speak to him. Day after day she asked, until the crocodile grew so miserable and so worn down that he gave in.

The next morning he swam to the tree.

"Friend," he said, "my wife is grateful for the fruit. She has cooked a meal for you and asks you to come to our home tonight."

"I would like that very much," said the monkey. "But I cannot swim."

"Sit on my back," said the crocodile.

So the monkey climbed down and sat on the crocodile's broad back, and they set off across the river.

Halfway across

When they were far out in the deep water, with the bank behind them small and green and very far away, the crocodile could not bear it any longer.

"Friend," he said, "I must tell you the truth. My wife does not want to feed you. She wants to eat your heart."

The monkey's whole body went cold. But he did not move, and he did not shout, and when he spoke his voice was calm and cheerful.

"Oh! Why did you not say so at the start?"

The crocodile turned his head. "What do you mean?"

"Every monkey knows this," said the monkey. "We do not carry our hearts about with us. It is far too dangerous, jumping from branch to branch all day. We leave them hanging in the tree. Mine is hanging in the jamun tree this very moment. If you had told me, I would have brought it."

"Then what shall we do?" cried the crocodile.

"Take me back," said the monkey, "and I will fetch it."

The crocodile turned round at once and swam as fast as he could to the bank.

The moment they touched the shore, the monkey leapt off and went up the trunk in three jumps. He climbed to the very top branch and looked down.

"You foolish creature," he called. "Nobody keeps their heart in a tree. You had my friendship and you traded it for a meal. Go home to your wife, and do not come back."

And he never came down while the crocodile was watching.

Moral of the story

Presence of mind can save you when strength cannot. And a friend who will trade you away for something better was never really a friend.

Questions and answers

  1. Why did the monkey and the crocodile become friends?

    The monkey gave the crocodile sweet jamun fruit every day, and the two of them talked together for hours until a real friendship grew.

  2. Why did the crocodile's wife want the monkey's heart?

    She reasoned that if the fruit was so sweet, a monkey who had eaten only that fruit all his life must have an even sweeter heart.

  3. How did the crocodile trick the monkey into the river?

    He said his wife had cooked a meal for the monkey and offered to carry him across the water on his back.

  4. What clever lie did the monkey tell?

    He said monkeys leave their hearts hanging in trees for safety, and that his was still in the jamun tree.

  5. Why did the monkey refuse to come down at the end?

    Because he now knew the crocodile was willing to kill him. The friendship was over, and trusting him again would be dangerous.

Word meanings

jamun
A sweet purple Indian fruit that grows on tall trees.
hauled
Pulled or dragged himself along with effort.
horrified
Filled with shock and fear at something terrible.
presence of mind
The ability to think clearly and act well in a sudden emergency.

Questions about The Monkey and the Crocodile

What is the moral of The Monkey and the Crocodile?

The moral is that quick thinking can save your life in danger, and that a friend who is willing to betray you for personal gain is not a true friend.

What is the monkey's name in the Panchatantra?

The monkey is called Raktamukha, meaning 'red face', in the original Sanskrit text.

Why could the crocodile not simply eat the monkey in the water?

He believed the monkey's heart had been left behind in the tree, so eating him would have been pointless. His wife wanted the heart specifically.

Is The Monkey and the Crocodile a true story?

No. It is a fable, which is a made-up story using talking animals to teach a lesson about how people behave.