The Cave That Talked
Also known as Bolti Gufa
- 2 minute read
- Ages 6-10
- Panchatantra Stories
A lion named Kharanakhara had grown old and slow and had not eaten for three days.
He came across a cave in a hillside with tracks going in and out of it, and worked out that something lived there and would come back at dusk.
So he went inside and lay down in the dark at the back and waited.
The jackal comes home
The cave belonged to a jackal named Dadhipuchchha, and he came home at sunset as usual.
He stopped some distance from the entrance.
There were tracks going in that were not his, and they were large, and there were none coming out. He had lived there long enough to know exactly what the ground outside his own door normally looked like.
He did not go in. He also did not run, because if the thing inside was fast, running would only tell it where he was.
The conversation
He stood at a safe distance and called out cheerfully.
"Cave! I am home!"
Nothing happened.
"Cave," he said again, louder, "you know the arrangement. Every evening when I come back, you call out to me and tell me it is safe to come in. That is what we agreed. I am waiting."
Inside, the lion listened to this and thought about it.
He had never heard of a talking cave, but he had never lived in one either, and if this was the arrangement and the cave stayed silent, the jackal would clearly not come in. And he had not eaten for three days.
So the lion answered.
"COME IN," said the cave, in a voice that shook loose stones from the roof.
Afterwards
Dadhipuchchha left the district.
He said afterwards that he had not been certain there was anything in there at all until the cave answered, and that he had asked precisely because it cost him nothing to ask, and that in his experience the answer to a stupid question tells you a great deal more than silence ever does.
Moral of the story
A test costs nothing if you are standing somewhere safe when you run it. Dadhipuchchha asked a ridiculous question and it saved his life.
Questions and answers
- Why did the lion hide in the cave?
He was old, slow and had not eaten for three days, so he waited for whatever lived there to come home.
- What made the jackal suspicious?
There were large tracks going into his cave and none coming out, and he knew what the ground outside his door normally looked like.
- Why did the jackal not run away?
If the animal inside was fast, running would only reveal where he was.
- What did he shout?
That the cave always called out to tell him it was safe to come in, and that he was waiting for it to do so.
- Why did the lion answer?
He had never lived in a cave, could not be sure it was untrue, and was too hungry to let the jackal walk away.
Word meanings
- tracks
- Marks left on the ground by an animal's feet.
- arrangement
- An agreement about how something is usually done.
- district
- An area or part of a country.
- ridiculous
- Very silly.
Questions about The Cave That Talked
What is the moral of The Cave That Talked?
That testing something from a safe distance costs nothing and can tell you everything. The jackal was not certain until the cave answered.
Why is the lion fooled by such a silly trick?
Because he has no way to check it. He has never lived in a cave, and hunger makes him take the chance rather than lose the meal.
What does the jackal's name mean?
Dadhipuchchha means 'curd-tail' in Sanskrit, describing a jackal with a pale tail.
What is a good discussion for children?
Ask what test they could run on something suspicious that would not put them in danger. The jackal's question is the whole model.